an essay on AI transformation

The motor is not the transformation.

Electricity took forty years to pay off. Not because of the motor, but because of the factory around it. It is the most useful lesson we have for AI.

01 1883 — 1910s

Factories swapped the engine, not the factory.

1883. A year after Edison begins selling electricity as a commodity, the first factory machines run on electric power.

Most factories do the obvious thing: they replace the steam engine with one large electric motor. Same shafts, same belts, same multi-storey building.

Then came group drive: smaller motors, each turning a section of shaft. Not a mistake: it was how factories learned electricity without stopping production.

Exhibit A How American factories were powered

steam engineone big motor5.3%a year: total factor productivity growth, US manufacturing, 1919–1929
Devine (1983); David (1990).

02 1899 — 1919

For twenty years, electricity was everywhere except in the productivity numbers.

In 1899, electric motors supplied less than 5% of the power driving American factory machines.

By 1919 they supplied more than half. Electrification was the defining investment of a generation of managers.

Yet productivity barely moved: about 0.7% a year in the decades to 1909. Dynamos were “everywhere but in the productivity statistics”.

Exhibit B Electrification of US factories, and productivity

Electric motors, share of factory drive power (US)

Electric motors as a share of factory drive power, US manufacturing: under 5% in 1899, about 25% in 1909, over 53% in 1919, about 78% in 1929.0%25%50%75%100%1899190919191929<5%25%53%78%
Electric share of factory drive power
YearShare
1899under 5%
1909about 25%
1919over 53%
1929about 78%
Electric share of mechanical drive capacity: Devine (1983). Total factor productivity, US manufacturing: David & Wright (1999).

03 The 1920s

The gains came when factories were redesigned around the new power.

Then the logic flipped. Every machine got its own motor: unit drive, not widespread until the 1920s.

With no shafts to align, the factory became single-storey, lit from above and laid out along the flow of materials.

Productivity growth rose to 5.3% a year in 1919–1929. Group drive had built the skills. Redesigning the factory turned them into growth.

Exhibit A, continued Unit drive and the single-storey factory

steam engineone big motor5.3%a year: total factor productivity growth, US manufacturing, 1919–1929
David (1990); David & Wright (1999); Devine (1983).

04 Today

Adopting AI and transforming with AI are two different moves.

Adoption puts AI in everyone’s hands: copilots, assistants, chat. It is today’s group drive, and it is necessary: it builds literacy, trust and quick wins.

Integration wires AI into existing workflows: a step is drafted, checked or routed by a model. Same process, faster steps.

Transformation redesigns the work around what AI makes cheap. The process changes, and so does the P&L.

Each stage is measured differently: usage, then cycle time, then outcomes. Mixing them up is how adoption gets reported as transformation.

Exhibit C Three stages, three ways to measure them

Stage 1

Adopt

What changes
Who uses AI
You measure
Usage, hours saved
In a claims team
A copilot drafts letters

Stage 2

Integrate

What changes
How each step is done
You measure
Cycle time, quality
In a claims team
AI reads documents into the file

Stage 3

Transform

What changes
How the work is designed
You measure
Outcomes on the P&L
In a claims team
Simple claims settled in a day

05 2022 — 2025

The model is becoming a commodity. What surrounds it is not.

The cost of running a model at GPT-3.5 level fell more than 280-fold between November 2022 and October 2024.

Open models closed the gap with closed ones, from 8% to 1.7% in a year. The two best models are 0.7% apart.

When everyone can rent the same model, the advantage moves to what surrounds it. First, data and technology: proprietary data, compute, integration into your systems.

Then people and organisation: domain experts, skills, leaders who steer the change, redesigned workflows, trust and governance. This is where most of the work is.

And finally the market: access to customers, positioning, brand, partners, regulation. The model is the motor. The moat is everything around it.

Exhibit D The motor gets cheaper; the advantage moves around it

Cost of running a model at GPT-3.5 level (index, Nov 2022 = 100)

Nov 2022100
Oct 20240.36

280× cheaper in two years

Hardware costs fell about 30% a year; energy efficiency improved about 40% a year.

Performance gap between models, % of score

Open vs closed models8.01.7
Best vs 10th-best model11.95.4
Best vs second-best model0.7
04812%

a year earlier in the 2025 report

  1. 1 Data & technology
  2. 2 People & organisation
  3. 3 Market & positioning
Proprietary dataCompute & cloudIntegrationDomain expertsPeople & skillsLeaders & changeRedesigned workflowsTrust & governanceAccess to customersMarket positioningBrand & reputationPartners & ecosystemRegulationAI model

AI model

1Data & technology

  • Proprietary data
  • Compute & cloud
  • Integration

2People & organisation

  • Domain experts
  • People & skills
  • Leaders & change
  • Redesigned workflows
  • Trust & governance

3Market & positioning

  • Access to customers
  • Market positioning
  • Brand & reputation
  • Partners & ecosystem
  • Regulation
Stanford HAI, AI Index Report 2025: inference cost of a GPT-3.5-level system, Nov 2022 – Oct 2024; performance gaps between models on leading benchmarks, 2024 vs 2023.

06 2024 — 2026

Everyone is adopting AI. It depends who you ask.

53% of people used generative AI within three years: faster than the personal computer or the internet.

78% of organisations say they use AI somewhere in the business.

Official statistics are far lower: about 18% of US firms used AI in a business function at the end of 2025.

And only about 5% of custom enterprise AI tools reach production. Between using AI and running on AI is where the value leaks.

Where the work itself is redesigned, the effect is concrete: physicians report up to 83% less time writing notes.

Exhibit E Four measures of AI adoption, four answers

0%

of people used generative AI within three years of launch

People · Stanford AI Index 2026

0%

of organisations say they use AI somewhere

Organisations, self-reported · Stanford AI Index 2025

0%

of US firms use AI in a business function

Firms, official statistics · US Census Bureau, end of 2025

0%

of custom enterprise AI tools reach production

Tools in production · MIT NANDA 2025, indicative

up to 83%

less time spent writing clinical notes, where hospitals redesigned the work around ambient AI scribes

Work redesigned · Stanford AI Index 2026

Different populations and definitions: four measures, not one funnel.

Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026 and 2025; US Census Bureau, Business Trends and Outlook Survey, via Federal Reserve FEDS Notes (Apr 2026); MIT NANDA, The GenAI Divide (2025), methodology indicative.

07 Redesign the work

One claim, three ways to run it.

As it runs today: seven steps across three teams. Most of the time is not work, it is waiting between hand-offs.

With AI on every step, letters are drafted, documents read and amounts suggested. Each step gets faster; the route stays the same.

Redesigned: photos and policy data arrive with the claim, and AI checks cover and estimates the damage at once. Simple claims are settled in a day.

People move to where judgment matters: complex, contested or suspicious claims, with the whole file in front of them.

Exhibit F A motor insurance claim, from first notice to payment

CustomerClaimshandlersSpecialists3 days4 days2 dayssimple claims · same daycomplex claimsReportthe claimRegisterCheckcoverSenddocumentsInspectdamageAssessamountGetpaidAI checks coverand estimates damageSpecialistcomplex cases
Steps
7733 + 1
Hand-offs
6623
Simple claim settled in
weeksdaysa daya day
People work on
every stepevery step, assistedchecksjudgment calls
Illustrative process, typical of property and casualty insurers. Times are indicative.

08 Build the case

Every business case starts from an outcome.

Efficiency: the same output for less cost or time. In claims, the driver is handling cost; the lever, straight-through processing.

Growth: more revenue from the same customers and channels. The driver is conversion; the lever, instant and personal quotes.

Quality: fewer errors and less rework. The driver is the accuracy of decisions; the lever, checks on every claim, not a sample.

Risk: fewer losses, frauds and breaches. The driver is leakage; the lever, fraud and anomaly detection running on every claim.

Experience: what customers and employees feel. The driver is time to settle; the lever, same-day decisions and proactive updates.

A use case without an outcome is a demo. Outcome first, then driver, then KPI, and only then the AI.

Exhibit G From outcome to AI lever: a value tree

Efficiency

Handling cost per claim

Cost per claim · cycle time

Straight-through processing of simple claims

Growth

Quote-to-policy conversion

Conversion rate · premium per customer

Instant, personalised quotes

Quality

Accuracy of decisions

Error rate · rework

AI checks on every claim, not a sample

Risk

Claims leakage and fraud

Leakage % · loss ratio

Fraud and anomaly detection

Experience

Time to settlement

Days to settle · NPS

Proactive updates, same-day decisions

Illustrative drivers and levers for an insurer; the structure applies to any business.

09 The playbook

Rewiring a business around AI, in five moves.

  1. Move 01Adopt

    Start from the outcome.

    Efficiency, growth, quality, risk or experience: name the one the business case must move, the driver behind it and the KPI that proves it. Then choose the AI.

    AskWhich number must move, and by how much?

  2. Move 02Adopt

    Adopt broadly, transform deeply.

    Give everyone the tools: adoption builds literacy and trust. Then pick one or two domains with a single owner and redesign them end to end, instead of fifty pilots.

    AskWhich domain will we redesign first?

  3. Move 03Transform

    Redesign the flow, not the step.

    Map the work as it really runs, hand-offs and waiting included. Remove the steps that only moved information, and put people where judgment matters.

    AskWhich steps only exist to move information?

  4. Move 04Transform

    Build what surrounds the model.

    Models are becoming a commodity. Data, domain experts, skills, governance and access to customers are not: invest there, and make them reusable across domains.

    AskWhat do we have that a competitor cannot rent?

  5. Move 05Scale

    Measure outcomes, not usage.

    Licences and hours saved are inputs. Track the KPI you named at the start, domain by domain, and stop what does not move it.

    AskWhat did the KPI do this quarter?

The motor is not the transformation. The factory is.

Adoption puts the motor in every hand, and it is where everyone starts. Transformation rebuilds the factory around it. The model is becoming a commodity; the factory is still yours to design.

References

Bibliography

  1. David, P. A. (1990). “The Dynamo and the Computer: An Historical Perspective on the Modern Productivity Paradox.” American Economic Review, 80(2), 355–361. econbiz.de
  2. David, P. A. & Wright, G. (1999). General Purpose Technologies and Surges in Productivity: Historical Reflections on the Future of the ICT Revolution. University of Oxford, Discussion Papers in Economic and Social History, No. 31. nuffield.ox.ac.uk
  3. Devine, W. D. Jr. (1983). “From Shafts to Wires: Historical Perspective on Electrification.” The Journal of Economic History, 43(2), 347–372. cambridge.org
  4. Federal Reserve Board (2026). “Monitoring AI Adoption in the U.S. Economy.” FEDS Notes, April 3, 2026. federalreserve.gov
  5. MIT NANDA (2025). The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025. Methodology reported inconsistently; the figure used here is indicative. Coverage: Fortune, 18 August 2025
  6. Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (2025). The AI Index 2025 Annual Report. hai.stanford.edu
  7. Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (2026). The AI Index 2026 Annual Report. hai.stanford.edu
  8. US Census Bureau (2026). The Microstructure of AI Diffusion: Evidence from Firms, Business Functions, and Worker Tasks. Center for Economic Studies Working Paper CES-WP-26-25. census.gov

Exhibits C, F and G are illustrative: they show a method, not measured data.